Cook needs his batsmen to dig in and beat the odds

History books stack up against England victory in Third Test starting tomorrow
P59 Ian Bell
Stephen Brenkley4 December 2012

England have won one Test match in Kolkata in their entire history. India have won five of the last seven and have not lost here since they were beaten by Pakistan in 1999.

That, in case anybody was getting ahead of themselves after the superlative win that levelled the four-match series in Mumbai last week, is the measure of the task awaiting the tourists in the Third Test which begins tomorrow.

As Alastair Cook, the England captain, put it today: “It’s given us a lot of confidence. It’s given us a belief that what we’re doing is the right stuff. It doesn’t mean it’s going to count for anything when we play this game.”

The days leading up to the match have been dominated by the state of the pitch and the wise old groundsman, Prabir Mukherjee, has soaked up the attention with an ever-present twinkle in his eye.

Since the strip was used for a Ranji Trophy match two weeks ago it is likely to turn early, perhaps as early as the first day. But pitch reading is a slightly less exact science than palmistry and the last three Tests at Eden Gardens have all featured India first innings totals of more than 600.

Neither Cook nor his counterpart, MS Dhoni, were giving much away today about the composition of their sides but the smart money is on them both having attacks comprising two fast bowlers and two spinners.

England look prepared to drop vice-captain, Stuart Broad, and while Cook was careful not to let anything slip, he was unstinting in his praise for the likely replacement, Steve Finn. “He’s got a little bit more pace than the other guys and he’s bowled well on the sub-continent before,” he said.

It would be a mistake to assume that spin will dominate as it did in Mumbai, where the England spinners, Graeme Swann and Monty Panesar, took 19 of the 20 wickets. History, ancient and modern, suggest that pace will have a part to play in the first innings.

There is a feeling that reverse swing could also be significant, which may please England. Their pace bowlers have claimed only two wickets in the series so far, both of them falling to Jimmy Anderson.

Broad has taken 40 Test wickets this year, more than any other seam bowler except Vernon Philander, of South Africa, who has had an exemplary sequence of matches. But he has been distinctly off the pace in every sense in India.

Dropping Broad would be a big call, not least because of his status in the side but equally it would be perverse to keep Finn waiting any longer.

Dhoni has made no apologies for his continual pleas for pitches favouring spin and returned to the theme today. He said: “It is playing to our strengths but the important thing is to play wickets which give both sides a chance to win and the challenge is for people to be tested in different conditions.”

In a radical move away from their normal policy of strict continuity, England are likely to make a second change to a winning side. Ian Bell, who has returned after paternity leave, will probably replace Jonny Bairstow.

Whatever the bowlers do and not do, the engine room of the batting order has to start delivering for England to have a chance of prevailing.

No half-century has been scored yet by England’s No3, No5 or No6 in the first two matches and if that does not change at Eden Gardens the wave of optimism prompted by the Mumbai win could swiftly recede.

Bell owes England runs as much as anybody. His class is not in question but he has made 522 runs in 21 innings this year at an average of 29. He is certain that the birth of his son, Joe, two weeks ago will lend a fresh perspective to his batting.

England have not played a Test match at Eden Gardens for 20 years. On their last visit they fielded four seamers and were promptly outclassed by India’s three spinners.

The balance of the sides will be more or less equal this time and first innings runs, albeit slowly accumulated, will be as significant as ever.

India were chastened by their heavy defeat in Mumbai and everywhere they go there are questions about the futures of Dhoni as captain and Sachin Tenduklar as a player.

They will only become more strident if they fail here. England can expect a response on a grand scale but, with Mumbai fresh in their minds, the chances of adding to their victory 35 years ago should not be discounted.

Create a FREE account to continue reading

eros

Registration is a free and easy way to support our journalism.

Join our community where you can: comment on stories; sign up to newsletters; enter competitions and access content on our app.

Your email address

Must be at least 6 characters, include an upper and lower case character and a number

You must be at least 18 years old to create an account

* Required fields

Already have an account? SIGN IN

By clicking Create Account you confirm that your data has been entered correctly and you have read and agree to our Terms of use , Cookie policy and Privacy policy .

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Thank you for registering

Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged in