Tom Daley's husband Dustin Lance Black cleared of assaulting BBC presenter at Soho nightclub Freedom

Dustin Lance Black was cleared by a judge after she found BBC presenter Teddy Edwardes had told lies about the fracas at Soho nightspot Freedom
WEST END FINAL

Get our award-winning daily news email featuring exclusive stories, opinion and expert analysis

I would like to be emailed about offers, event and updates from Evening Standard. Read our privacy notice.

Olympic diver Tom Daley embraced husband Dustin Lance Black as the Oscar winner was cleared of assaulting a social media influencer in a Soho nightclub fracas.

Dustin Lance Black, 49, was accused grabbing Teddy Edwardes by the wrist and spilling her drink during the incident at the Freedom nightclub in Soho on August 18 last year.

However District Judge Louisa Cieciora stopped the trial at Westminster magistrates court after the prosecution case, and in an excoriating judgment she found Ms Edwardes had told lies, shattered her credibility with social media posts, and been evasive while giving evidence.

“I accept Ms Edwardes provided an account in which she confirmed Mr Black grabbed her wrist”, she said. “However the inconsistencies and weaknesses in her evidence go beyond simple matters of credibility and reliability to be determined at the end of the evidence. They are fundamental to the case.

Dustin Lance Black court case
PA

“For that reason, I consider the prosecution evidence taken at its highest is such that…I couldn’t properly convict Mr Black of the charge.”

Daley accompanied Black to court and sat patiently outside the hearing room alone for more than six hours, in anticipation of being called as a defence witness. But his evidence was not needed after a disastrous spell giving evidence by Ms Edwardes.

The couple shared an embrace moments after Black was released by the judge.

In a statement, the screenwriter said after his acquittal: "I am pleased that the judge saw the truth today and ruled in my favour.  As the evidence has proven, and I have always maintained, I am completely innocent, and in fact was the victim in this case of a serious assault. I am relieved this unfortunate matter is now over."

Ms Edwardes was confronted in court by her own social output, including cracking jokes about the incident, giving varying descriptions of the alleged assault, and referring to “pesky CCTV” at the heart of the case.

The British Diversity Awards 2023 - Arrivals
Love Island's Amber Gill was at the Freedom bar in Soho on the night of the fracas between Teddy Edwardes and Dustin Lance Black
Getty Images

The collapse of the case puts the spotlight on the Crown Prosecution Service’s decision to prosecute Black at all, especially as he had been assaulted himself by Ms Edwardes during the same incident.

Black and Daley were on a rare date night when they ended up in Freedom, and after the diver received unwanted attention from two fans they were invited to join Ms Edwardes’ table she was sharing with Love Island star Amber Gill.

“Essentially it’s an altercation in a nightclub”, said prosecutor Adrita Ahmed.

“The Crown’s case is the defendant grabbed Ms Edwardes’ wrist and twisted it, and the drink has gone over her. “Ms Edwardes has retaliated”, she added, revealing that the TV presenter received a caution in February over the incident for “going too far in self-defence”.

Giving evidence from behind a screen, Ms Edwardes said she did not know Tom Daley but offered to buy him a drink. The athlete said yes and added that his husband would want one as well, she said. The court heard Ms Edwardes, Ms Gill, and friends then joined Daley and Black in a booth.

At one point, she asked security to move another man from the area where they were sitting because he was making Ms Gill feel uncomfortable, and she noticed Black "didn't seem to be very happy with me".

A police video later revealed that Black believed Ms Edwardes had ejected the man because he was not a celebrity and she “didn’t want the non-famous person there”. An altercation later broke out when Black was "shouting at me that I had made him feel uncomfortable since I got there", said Ms Edwardes.

"I think he said he felt humiliated", she said. "I think I said I'm sorry, I didn't mean to make you feel like that."

Black, however, countered that Ms Edwardes, a BBC3 presenter and social media influencer had been the aggressive one, and also appeared to be drunk. She claimed: "I had a drink in my hand, and he grabbed my wrist and twisted it round so my drink would go all over me."

Black insisted in his police interview that he had never touched her wrist, and the drink was spilled when he reached out to take away her glass, believing she had drunk enough. Black, a US filmmaker with Oscar-winning screenplay Milk in his back catalogue, argued through his lawyer that the CCTV did not show him grabbing her wrist, while her evidence had been inconsistent.

“What the defence would say you can see on the CCTV is, immediately from the very beginning, Mr Black is trying to walk away”, said Helena Duong, representing Black.

“She turns to him and appears to reach out.

“There’s an exchange between them, in which she continues to be aggressive and shouting at him and he reacts to that.

“She makes a movement, gesticulating with her arms, which causes Mr Black to reach for the glass.”

Under cross-examination, Ms Edwardes was quizzed about her social media output in which she branded Black a "d***head" and said he "pretty much unprovoked threw an entire drink over me".

She added to her followers: "Tell me why he is crying outside saying it was a targeted attack, saying he is traumatised."

In some of her online content, Ms Edwardes characterised the punch she threw as a "tap", she referred to "pesky CCTV" , and admitted making repeated jokes about the incident.

Ms Duong suggested to Ms Edwardes: "What you did was to effectively exaggerate and add to what you say Mr Black did."

She also conceded she may have "come across as aggressive" towards the end of the confrontation with Black.

But she denied performing a "chest pump" in the seconds before the drink was spilled.

Dustin Lance Black court case
PA

In her application for the case to be dismissed, Ms Duong accused Ms Edwardes of repeatedly lying in court, to the police, and on social media where she suggested the drink had gone into her face rather than on the floor.

“When faced with such unreliable and inconsistent evidence that flies in the face of the evidence you have seen, you could put a stop to this”, she told the judge.

Black, who says he was left with post-concussion syndrome as a result of the punch and lost £600,000 in earnings, was cleared by the judge of one charge of common assault.

In her ruling, the judge took aim at parts of Ms Edwardes' evidence when she had been quizzed about her social media statements that were inaccurate and untrue.

"I did not consider her explanations, which included that she was angry when she wrote some of the posts, or social media is not real life, or she was limited in the number of characters she could use, to be at all persuasive."

Create a FREE account to continue reading

eros

Registration is a free and easy way to support our journalism.

Join our community where you can: comment on stories; sign up to newsletters; enter competitions and access content on our app.

Your email address

Must be at least 6 characters, include an upper and lower case character and a number

You must be at least 18 years old to create an account

* Required fields

Already have an account? SIGN IN

By clicking Create Account you confirm that your data has been entered correctly and you have read and agree to our Terms of use , Cookie policy and Privacy policy .

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Thank you for registering

Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged in